| |
KABBALAH? CABALA? QABALAH?
All these different spellings - and not just the ones
in the title: Kabbalah, Kabbala, Kaballah - there is also Kabala, Kabballah,
Kabalah, Kaballa, Kabballa, what shall we make of it?
And then there are the "C" spellings: Cabbalah,
Cabbala, Caballah, Cabala, Cabballah, Cabalah, Caballa, Cabballa.
And let us not forget about the "Q" spellings:
Qabbalah, Qabbala, Qaballah, Qabala, Qabballah, Qabalah, Qaballa, Qabballa.
There are a total of 24 possible spellings, as in the following table:
|
Cabala
|
Kabala
|
Qabala
|
|
Cabalah
|
Kabalah
|
Qabalah
|
|
Caballa
|
Kaballa
|
Qaballa
|
|
Caballah
|
Kaballah
|
Qaballah
|
|
Cabbala
|
Kabbala
|
Qabbala
|
|
Cabbalah
|
Kabbalah
|
Qabbalah
|
|
Cabballa
|
Kabballa
|
Qabballa
|
|
Cabballah
|
Kabballah
|
Qabballah
|
First things first, let's consider the first-letter
choices. "C" (as in Cabbala, Cabala, etc.); or "K" (as in Kabbalah, Kabala,
etc.); or "Q" (as in Qabala, Qabalah, etc.).
Some pundits posit as a general guideline, i.e., not
100% of the cases, that whereas Jews spell it with a "K" (Kabbalah, etc.),
Christians tend to use a "C" (Cabala, etc.) while the occultists tend towards
the "Q" (Qabalah, etc.).
Next, to consider the last not last, is the question
of the final "H" (as in Cabalah, Kabbalah, Qabalah, etc., but not in Cabala,
Kabala, Qabbala, etc.).
This variation is usually a reflection of
pronunciation practices, so here I'll stick to Jewish orthography. The word has
three syllables. The final "H" (Kabbalah, etc.) is to induce you to emphasize
the final syllable, while its omission (Kabala, etc.) leads to middle syllable
stress.  | | " ...how silly it would be to have cosher cabala or qosher qabalah!" |  |  |
Speaking of middle, doubling the "b" (Kabbalah, etc.)
or not (Kabala, etc.) and/or doubling the "l" (Kaballah, Kabballah, etc.) or not
(Kabbalah, Kabalah, etc.) is also a manifestation of the effort to invoke
correct pronunciation, in this case the three short "a" vowels as well as
correct syllable stress. I refuse to elaborate further, as the theories here are
inconsistent and even contradictory.
As for Kosher Kabbala (Kosher Kabbalah, Kosher
Kaballah, Kosher Kabala, Kosher Kabballah, Kosher Kabalah, Kosher Kaballa,
Kosher Kabballa), in this case it is probably safe to drop the "C" and "Q"
options according to the above principle, because the term 'kosher' can be
applied only to authentic Jewish Kabbala (Kabbalah, Kabala, etc.). Anyway, look
how silly it would be to have "cosher cabala" or "qosher qabalah"!
This does not mean that every "K" internet site or
print book is authentic; far from it. Only a few are. Many if not most kosher
Kabbalah websites can be found on our links page and the English version
books on our reading lists. But at least you know that the chances are
better than on any of the "C" (Cabbalah, Cabbala, Caballah, Cabala, Cabballah,
Cabalah, Caballa, Cabballa) or "Q" (as in Qabbalah, Qabbala, Qaballah, Qabala,
Qabballah, Qabalah, Qaballa, Qabballa) sites.
Oh yes, about the main spelling variations based on
pronunciation difference. As I mentioned above, this variation is usually a
manifestation of accent distinctions, with the final "H" indicating emphasis on
the final syllable, while its omission leads to middle syllable stress. I think
it is safe to say that the latter (Kabbala, Kabala, Kaballa, etc.) reflects the
Ashkenazic Jewish manner of pronounciation, while the former (Kabalah, Kabbalah,
Kaballah, etc.) indicates the Sephardic way.
But for kosher Kabbala (Kosher Kabbalah?, Kosher
Kaballah?, Kosher Kabala?) sites and books, how they spell it and how you
pronounce it are of virtually no significance. What counts is that for the
product to be kosher, the Kabbalists (Cabbalists, Cabalists, Qabbalists,
Qabalists) or whoever is producing it have to be impeccably kosher themselves,
faithful to the unbroken chain of Jewish traditional teachings since the Mount
Sinai revelation.
|
Microsoft OLE DB Provider for SQL Server error '80040e57'
String or binary data would be truncated.
/componentskab/feedbacktracking/feedbacktrackingform.asp, line 139 | |